Ke aneiai kuwaho o keʻokeʻo a me ka ulaula ma ke Kanawai War

Iloko o ke Kanawai War, keʻokeʻo a me kaʻulaʻula mea a pau i imi e loaʻa ai ka mana a me ka piha loa ia'na o kaʻenemi. Ke confrontation ua ole wale ma ke alo, akā, me ka nui no hoi na, ao ke ano, a me ka waiwai kaiaulu. Mamua o ka ua kālailai e ka aneiai kuwaho o keʻokeʻo a me ka ulaula ma ke Kanawai War, e pono e aʻo i ke kumu o kaʻokoʻa ma waena o ka mau ideologies confrontation i alakai aku ai i ke kaua fratricidal.

Key, ao ke ano o ka ulaula-hoʻokele waiwai

Red i i ike i kekahi waiwai, kokua aku i ka manaʻo i kanaka a pau e e like i loko o nā ka loio a me ka pilina hua'ōlelo. No kaʻulaʻula ke aliʻi ka mea, ua i ka noho luna ana, ka waiwai, a me ka mea hoʻowahāwahāʻia ka pilina a me ka hana papa, ma ko lakou manao, ua lilo i ke alakai 'ole o ka moku'āina. Hoomanaʻulaʻula manaoio aku i ka opiuma o na kanaka. Church luku, i manaoio mercilessly exterminated, atheists i ua paʻa ma kiʻekiʻeʻia.

hilinaʻi keʻokeʻo

No ka keʻokeʻo mō'ī-makua, o ka papa, ka mea, ua i ka mana, imperial mana - i ke kumu o ke kānāwai a me ka mea i loko o ka moku'āina. Lakou i wale ike i kekahi waiwai, akā, ua noʻonoʻo ia i ka nui milestone o ka aina o ka pomaikai. Ke intelligentsia, 'epekema a me ka hoʻonaʻauao' ana i ua paʻa ma kiʻekiʻeʻia.

White i i noonoo ai i na Rusia me ka manaoio. Orthodoxy - ke kihi. Ma ka mea, i ka nānā 'ana moʻomeheu, wahine paha, a me ka pomaikai o ka lahui.

Ke kākoʻo like ideologies

hiki i alakai i ka confrontation Polar kālai'āina o kaʻulaʻula, a keʻokeʻo. Ka papaʻaina maopopo hōʻike i nāʻokoʻa:

Social, nohona kanaka, a-yeiiiie? Kuwaho o kaʻulaʻula keʻokeʻo, a loaʻa iā ia kona ardent kākoʻo a me ka poe enemi. Ke aupuni Ua maheleia. Hapalua kākoʻo i kaʻulaʻula, ka mea'ē aʻe - keʻokeʻo.

Policy White i ke Kanawai War

Denikin moe o ka lā o Rusia, e hou lilo i ka nui a me ka indivisible. General manaoio i pono e kaua aku i ka Bolsheviks a hiki i ka hopena, a e ho'ōla loa luku aku ia lakou. I ka wa e aponoia ka "Hōʻike", a ua mālama i nā mea nona ka pono i ka aina, e like me ka pono me ua hoakaka no ka pono o ka hana kanaka. Denikin rescinded i ka manao paa o ke Aupuni Kuikawa, o ka mōhaiʻai monopoly, a ua hoi ulu ka manao no ka "aina kānāwai" e like me ka mea a ke kanaka e kuai i ka aina, mai ka haku hale.

Makakoho ma aneiai kulekele Kolchak i ka puunaue ana o ka aina a me ka aina-pōloli kauwa, ka poe mahiʻai, ka poe e ole i aina. Kolchak manao e hopu i ka ula waiwai - Ua ākeʻakeʻa a me ka looting. A pau i ka loot E e hoi aku i ka mea nona - na nā haku, konohiki.

Wrangell hana pili aupuni mihi, e like me ka mea i kali nui landholdings, a mahuahua nui allotments no waena kauwa, e like me ka pono me ua hoakaka no ka kua'āina ua hanaʻia waiwai.

A me Denikin a me Wrangel a me Kolchak hōʻoki aku Bolshevik "hoʻolahaʻia ke kānāwai ma luna o Land", akā, e like me ka mōʻaukala E hoike mai, i ole i hiki ke hele mai me ka credible koho. Unsustainability aneiai nā mea hoʻololi keʻokeʻo pololei o ka mea ka fragility o kēia aupuni. Ināʻaʻole no ka mea waiwai, a me kou kōkua i Ally, ina ua haule nui mamua o ka keʻokeʻo? Eia.

Policy Reds ma ke Kanawai War

Red i ke Kanawai War, hoohana i kekahi "olelo paa ma Land", i hoopau ia ponoi ona o ka'āina, a, e kau ia Iosepa, i ole makemake i ka landowners, akā, ua hauʻoli kūkala nūhou no ka maʻamau kanaka. Maoli ai,ʻaʻole landless kauwa a me ka poe e hana ana i kekahi mihi o Denikin a Kolchak a me Wrangel HOU he ai hookipa ana a me ka olelo mua iaʻi, e like me ka mea paa o ka Bolsheviks.

Ka Bolsheviks 'Imi hahai aku la i ke kulekele o ke "kaua communism", e like me a ka Soviet aupuni, ua ma luna o ka piha nationalization o ka hoʻokele waiwai. Ke nationalization o ka hoʻokele waiwai ho ka naeaeaa mai kekahi i ka lehulehu lima. E like me monopoly o ka hoʻolauna haole kalepa. Ua Ua nationalized'auwaʻa. Ke kūkaʻi 'ana, nā alakaʻi pāʻoihana koke nalowale ka waiwai. Na Bolsheviks imi iho la e hoʻonui loa centralize ana o ka hoʻokele waiwai 'ana o Rusia.

He nui HOU ka mea,ʻaʻole ano o kanaka makemake. I kekahi o kēia mau meaʻawaʻawa loa HOU ua i ka hoʻokomo 'ia' o ka muli o ka hana lawelawe, a papa aku akeakea kuleana ka hoʻololiʻana i ka hou 'oihana, e like me absenteeism. Ka mea, ua wahahee "no ka naau mai hana" a me ka "Lāpule a me ka" - o ka'ōnaehana o kaa hana, i mea OAXA no a pau.

Food Bolshevik dictatorship

Ka Bolsheviksʻike ihola i ka monopoly ma luna o ka berena, a ma kekahi manawa i? Aaeaaaaony i ke Aupuni Kūikawā. Na Makuahine Ua hoʻolauna ma ka Soviet aupuni no ke kua'āina bourgeoisie, ka mea i hūnāʻia ka palaoa laau. He nui nā moʻolelo kuhikuhi mai i ka mea, ua i ka pono? Aiaiiuie ana, no ka mea, ma hope o ka mea kipi waiho i ke aupuni i loko o hina, a pela i ka redistribution e kōkua e ola i loko o ka wiwi makahiki. Eia naʻe, ua alakai nui excesses ma ke kula a hiki i ka nui expropriation o nā mea a pau ka ai ana i loko o kua'āina wahi, kūpono ai i loko o ka nui wi, a me ka loa kiʻekiʻe make kōmi.

Penei, kaumaha kāna hana e lawelawe i aneiai kulekele o keʻokeʻo a me kaʻulaʻula. Hoʻohālike o ke kumu, ao ke ano ua hāʻawiʻia i loko o ka papaʻaina ma lalo:

E like me ka papaʻaina E hoike mai, i ka waiwai kuwaho o ke keʻokeʻo a me kaʻulaʻula ua pono ke ku pono.

Haahaa ia i loko o nāʻaoʻao

Policy o keʻokeʻo a me ka ulaula ma ke Kanawai War radically okoa. Eia naʻe, aole hoi kekahi o lakou, i ole 100% ka hoʻokō. Kēlā me KUMUMANAʻO NUI kuhikuhi i kona keakea.

"War Communism" Ua nema aku a hiki i ka Communists lakou iho. Ma hope iho o ka hookamaia o kēia kulekele, no ka Bolsheviks manao i ke kūkaʻi 'ulu o ka hoʻokele waiwai, akā, ma ka ike maopopo a pau uaʻokoʻa. All pāʻoihana e hoʻokele waiwai illiterate, kūpono i ka ho'ēmi i kā productivity, e starving kanaka, a i ike nui mahiʻai i he kumu hoʻopaipai e recycle. Hoemiia hanalima auaiaea, aia no he emi ma ka mahiai. Ma ke kālā kaiaulu hana hyperinflation, a ua ole no hoi i ke alii a me ke Aupuni Kūikawā. People mowed pololi.

Ka nui drawback o keʻokeʻo eia, yeieiae? Ua lākou hikiʻole, e lawe mai i ka manaʻo aukahi aina pilikino E pili. Aole hoi Wrangel aole hoi Denikin a Kolchak, a i ole ulu i ke kānāwai i makemake kākoʻo i nā nā paʻi hua i loko o ka maka o nā hana a me nā kauwa. Eia hou, i ka fragility o ka keʻokeʻo mana i i ae ia e hoopau ai i ke ike i ko lakou ulu ana kuka no ka hoʻokele waiwai o ka aina o ka.